On Deadline: What would be YOUR top 10 local news stories -- over 50 years? | Off Deadline | Jay Thorwaldson | Palo Alto Online |

Local Blogs

Off Deadline

By Jay Thorwaldson

About this blog: I was editor of the Palo Alto Weekly from June 2000 to January 2011, capping a more than 50-year career in journalism and writing since Los Gatos High School, where I was editor of the student newspaper and president of the speech...  (More)

View all posts from Jay Thorwaldson

On Deadline: What would be YOUR top 10 local news stories -- over 50 years?

Uploaded: Mar 9, 2011
First of three columns/blogs on my Top 10 choices.

I was at a bit of a loss about what to talk about when I was invited recently to speak at the Palo Alto Rotary Club following my Jan. 31 retirement as Palo Alto Weekly editor.

There have been thousands of stories, columns, editorials and adventures over my five decades of being a full- or part-time journalist. Pressed for a topic to meet a newsletter/announcement deadline, I blurted out: "OK. I'll talk about the Top 10 news stories I've covered."

Easier said than done. I began wishing I'd said "Top Three." For days, as last Monday's talk drew closer, the term "Top 10" cycled through my brain. I jotted notes, winnowed topics, compared interest, significance, and how I personally felt about the story. This was MY Top 10, after all.

At last I opened my laptop and began putting things down. But first I had to define "story," which can be anything from a single article to a continuing topic that encompasses many articles, columns, even editorials. Then I had to find a way to present all these stories within the allocated 30 minutes allocated. I'll hustle through some, I thought, so I have more room for the big Top Three -- also easier said than done. To keep myself on time, I turned to PowerPoint.

So here they are, in three parts -- working up to Number One as they do on TV:

Number 10 is a sad one of more than a half century ago, but it has echoes as timely as today's news. I was editor of the El Gato student newspaper at Los Gatos High School in 1957, under a great teacher/adviser, Elizabeth Girdler. A young woman, Connie, ran her car into a tree between Los Gatos and Saratoga at 85 miles an hour at 6:30 a.m. in her flannel nightdress. It was the same tree that killed a young man, also a fellow student, a year earlier in what was most likely a simple crash due to speeding and a slight dip in the roadway.

Connie had just been rejected for a part in the senior play. Two aspects made this a special story: A paparazzi-like group of journalists cornered the distraught father. One shoved a tape recorder in his face and asked why he thought she had done it. The father mumbled something about there perhaps being "a James Dean cult" at the school, as Dean's death was still recent.

The media pounced. With no effort whatsoever to check out his fantasy of grief, Connie's yearbook photo showed up on front pages nationally and in Europe with variants of the headline: "James Dean cult at Los Gatos High School." I was deeply angered at this act of irresponsible, incompetent reporting. It has stayed with me as a core guideline of responsible professionalism ever since. I'm still mad.

The second aspect was that we followed up on the story. We checked the cast lists of the senior play, the junior play, the sophomore skits and the freshman frolics over four years and found that most of the on-stage parts went essentially to the same group of kids, a kind of "drama clique" that had shut Connie out. We added up the cost of the drama program, printed an article, followed with an editorial that, as I recall, said a program that cost that much should be broader than benefiting a "handful of teacher's pets."

I soon had my first (of more than a few) meetings with the school principal, and very nice man named Fred Canrinus. His daughter 20 or so years later told me that he "followed your career" when I was still at the Palo Alto Times in the late 1970s.

For Number 9, I chose a different kind of story: "My First Newspaper War."

Desperate for a summer job between my junior and senior years at San Jose State, I jumped at a job Professor Lamar Mackey called me about on a Thursday morning. A publisher, he said, was desperately seeking an editor for a chain of weeklies in West Fresno County: the Mendota News, Firebaugh News and San Joaquin/ Tranquility News -- starting Friday morning. No way. Had a date Friday night.

But I pulled into Mendota before 8 a.m. Saturday morning, passed the scruffy office three times before finding it, and started the hardest 2 1/2 months of my life putting out three weeklies in an office with no air conditioning, a young publisher and his family, including his irascible 78-year-old father (a retired South San Francisco weekly publisher), a printer and a pressman younger than my 21 years and a series of drunken LinoType operators.

Yet the real story was how we put a rival publisher, a 20-year veteran of the Oakland Tribune, out of business after he purchased the Firebaugh Journal to the north. He had come into the Mendota News office when my publisher bought the chain, refused to shake hands, declared "This area's not big enough for the both of us," and stalked out. A jerk, in other words.

Soon after I returned to San Jose State I heard he turned the Journal back to the old publisher, giving up. I thought a lot about how a rank beginner was able to outmaneuver a veteran journalist who knew about everything -- and wasn't shy about telling everyone. My take-home lesson was that he made the locals feel small and "hicks," while my ignorant questions about simple zoning matters made them feel bigger and better.

Journalists should never let their heads outgrow their hat sizes.

My Number 8 story was "The First Manned Flight to Mars," while based in Mountain View for the Palo Alto Times in the mid-1960s. Part of my beat was Moffett Field and NASA, including Hangar One, science, a trip to Florida to watch the first solid-fuel rocket-assist launch and a five-part, detailed series on "The First Manned Flight to Mars." It never happened, of course. But it COULD have happened, back in the 1980s, I believe, according to the calculations of one scientist/mathematician.

The Mars-landing story was picked up worldwide by Associated Press and put the scientist who figured out how it could be done on the map, I was told later. "You really made his career," another NASA scientist told me.

Continued Friday, March 11, same place.
What is it worth to you?


Posted by Janice, a resident of ,
on Mar 9, 2011 at 11:26 pm

In my opinion, the most fundamental story in Palo Alto, in the last 50 years, was the decision to sell off public school land for development. Those properties should have been rented out to other entities, but not sold. It was a huge mistake. The proper model was Cubberley, not Hoover.

Posted by Jay Thorwaldson, a resident of ,
on Mar 10, 2011 at 4:43 pm

Jay Thorwaldson is a registered user.

Janice: Good nomination. The crisis of the 1970s in terms of plummeting school population was a major story, but it was covered by my colleague at the Palo Alto Times, the late Marc Salgado. Now if someone can predict accurately what will be happening in terms of student population 20 or 30 years from now. ...

Posted by Resident, a resident of ,
on Mar 10, 2011 at 5:42 pm

Jay, good question to Janice's excellent comment.

To answer your question, we have to look at the residences in Palo Alto. I am not sure how many residences were in Palo Alto in the 70s, but I am sure that we have increased the number of residences by a huge amount. Residences (as opposed to homes, apartments, complexes, etc.) are what produce school kids. The question may more accurately question the number of children enrolled in public schools as opposed to homeschooled or privately schooled.

The residences are not going away. If we look at the number of homes with more than 2 bedrooms it is indicative that these residences will hold children. Whether we are talking about 1 parent families, families who move in with grandparents, or even divorced parents with joint custody and both need to live in Palo Alto, we are talking about residences with children.

From what "everyone" says, people are moving to Palo Alto for the schools. In other areas of the Bay Area, schools are closing, merging, or struggling to stay open whereas in Palo Alto we are growing at an alarming rate. From this we must conclude that the schools are attracting more and more families and unless something catastrophic happens then the trend will continue. Even if the quality of the schools diminishes (an unlikely scenario) and we have a glut a housing that won't sell, we can see that the younger people who spur the high tech world in which we live will still be here having children that need to be educated and in the likelihood of having to close a public school it appears likely that a private school would be willing to step in and rent a premises.

Of course, the Palo Alto population could become empty nesters and decide to stay put, but with the cost of living in Palo Alto so much higher than elsewhere - even in the Bay Area, empty nesters will be able to downsize to a cheaper area (possibly into the same sized home) when they no longer need the good schools and empty their homes for more school aged families to move in.

I think the likelihood is that we will not be closing any public schools 20 or 30 years from now - that is unless Silicon Valley goes bust!

Posted by Janice, a resident of ,
on Mar 10, 2011 at 6:43 pm

Jay: Wrong question, in my view. Even if the student population plummets, for a while, it is wrong to sell off the public school sites. They can be leased out to other entities, both private and public, but they should not be sold. For example, Pinewood school was leased out, but not sold. Same with Garland and Cubberley. However, several public school sites were sold for development.

Professional demographers should be ignored, because they rely on past trends, and they are no better than the rest of us to determine future trends. American women in the 1970s decided to have very few children, but then it changed, and then there was immigration. Impossible to predict. The only thing we can do is to keep our precious public school lands.

Very big story.

Follow this blogger.
Sign up to be notified of new posts by this blogger.



Post a comment

Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.

Stay informed.

Get the day's top headlines from Palo Alto Online sent to your inbox in the Express newsletter.

Holiday Fun in San Francisco- Take the Walking Tour for An Evening of Sparkle!
By Laura Stec | 8 comments | 3,197 views

Boichik Bagels is opening its newest – and largest – location in Santa Clara this week
By The Peninsula Foodist | 0 comments | 2,238 views

I Do I Don't: How to build a better marriage Ch. 1, page 1
By Chandrama Anderson | 0 comments | 1,367 views


Palo Alto Weekly Holiday Fund

For the last 30 years, the Palo Alto Weekly Holiday Fund has given away almost $10 million to local nonprofits serving children and families. 100% of the funds go directly to local programs. It’s a great way to ensure your charitable donations are working at home.