Town Square

Post a New Topic

Loving the Elbe

Original post made by Thomas Stebinger on Sep 5, 2006

Dale Bentson asked for comment on the Elbe Restaurant in his review, which appeared in the July 28 Palo Alto Weekly. Web Link
Very well -- here is mine.

I love the Elbe and everything about it. It is the only place around here where you can get good German and Central European food at an affordable price, and I'd hate to lose it. I hope that it is not hurt by Bentson's mean-spirited and hostile review.

I've never found the variable quality that he cites, and since I've always eaten there at reasonable hours, I've not been troubled by noise from the bar next door. Why does he make such a big deal about this?

As to the food, I find Bentson's criticism erratic and nit-picking. I've never had the dried-up meat in any dish I've ordered. As for his comment on the limited wine list, I haven't tested it because I prefer beer, but I think it's unreasonable to compare it with what's available in a big gourmet restaurant, several times more expensive, with a "big name" chef and a sommelier.


Bentson reminds me of Michael Bauer's reviews in the Chronicle, who only reviews snooty restaurants that charge an arm and a leg and are priced far beyond what most of us can afford. Then, Bentson goes to the opposite extreme and compares Elbe's Kaswspaetzle with Kraft macaroni and cheese and asks why he can't have catsup with it.


Bentson doesn't seem to know what he wants Elbe to be, and it shows. To say the least, I was appalled by his review, which I found most ungenerous. I think he owes Elbe and its patrons an apology.

Comments (2)

Posted by Food lover, a resident of Crescent Park
on Sep 5, 2006 at 3:59 pm

Dale Benston is a poor food critic. He's probably the most mean-spirited food critic that I have ever read. Benston's reviews are often spiced with the kind of put-downs that you describe above - a level of insult that's completely without subtlty, and is just plain hurtful...there's no other way to say it.

As such, Benston confuses the elevated role of food critic - ideally meant to educate and inform - with the role of "guardian of personal preference", with Benston's special put-down sauce added in for good measure.

In one review some time ago (I think it was a review of an Italian restaurant, downtown), he claimed that NO retaurant in Palo Alto serves up authentic Italian fare. In doing so, he trashed the Italian restaurant that he was reviewing, as well as all the other Italian restaurants in Palo Alto. This is par for the course with Benston.

What's sad about this is that there are some VERY good Italian restaurants in Palo Alto. If I owned a restaurant, and advertised with the Weekly, I would do so on the condition that Benston not be permitted to review my restaurant. He's that bad.

Benston's often about whining about how this or that restaurant's decor is tacky (according to him). In fact, I read one of Benston's reviews that criticized the decor in alocal Italian restaurant for its tackiness. But if one visits local neighborhood eateries in Italy, one often sees the same kind of decor. This is just another example of ignorance on Benston's part, spewed forth in a local Weekly newspaper, with consequences that can be dire for a small restuarant like Elbe.

In all, I think the Weekly could do much better than Benston. There is nothing ELEVATING about his restaurant reviews. His are simply the opinions of one who appears to know a little more about some aspects of food than the average restaurant goer but with a big axe to grind(in fairness, Benston does offer an occasional insight or two, but it's more rare than 35-year-old balsamic vinegar).

What's mostunfortunate is that the restaurant business here is VERY challenging. There are many different kinds of restaurant competing for an undersupply of customers. Reviewing a restaurant the way that Benston so poorly reviewed Elbe can have a BIG effect on a restaurant's bottom line, impacting the lives of restaurant owners and their employees in ways that food critics of Benston's ilk are probably not aware. (another shortcoming)

In sum, Benston's reviews tend to be more about him than about the restaurant. This is a problem with many critics, in general. This is a shame, because the role of the critic has evolved from a great tradition of essayists and cultural commentators (including the culture of food)in the past (there are some good ones currently out there)to one today where almost anyone who can write a cogent paragraph and can talk the buzzword talk (food, theatre, film, automobiles, etc.)seems to qualify as "critic".

Whatcan we expect? the Weekly and Daily don't have big budgets; it's hard to find quality. In spite of that, the Weekly has managed to employ some reporters and a few critics that could actually write copy for the NYT;; they're that good. Unfortunately - for Elbe, Elbe's customers, and the many fine years of quality service that Elbe has offered - Dale Benston isn't one of them.


Posted by Melissa, a resident of Evergreen Park
on Nov 16, 2006 at 10:55 am

On the contrary, he is one critic who is not afraid to voice his opinion on mediocrity.


If you were a member and logged in you could track comments from this story.

Post a comment

Posting an item on Town Square is simple and requires no registration. Just complete this form and hit "submit" and your topic will appear online. Please be respectful and truthful in your postings so Town Square will continue to be a thoughtful gathering place for sharing community information and opinion. All postings are subject to our TERMS OF USE, and may be deleted if deemed inappropriate by our staff.

We prefer that you use your real name, but you may use any "member" name you wish.

Name: *

Select your neighborhood or school community: * Not sure?

Comment: *

Verification code: *
Enter the verification code exactly as shown, using capital and lowercase letters, in the multi-colored box.

*Required Fields

September food and drink goings on
By Elena Kadvany | 0 comments | 1,493 views

College Freshmen: Avoiding the Pitfalls
By John Raftrey and Lori McCormick | 1 comment | 1,292 views

Camp Glamp
By Laura Stec | 8 comments | 1,155 views

A Reprieve for Elon!
By Cathy Kirkman | 12 comments | 465 views

Twenty-five years of wedded bliss
By Sally Torbey | 2 comments | 188 views