Palo Alto Weekly

News - February 22, 2013

Website for detecting plagiarism is trading post for English papers

Students can run an 'originality check' before handing in papers on Turnitin.com

by Chris Kenrick

An Internet-based plagiarism detector has become not only a tool for teachers but also a plagiarism instructor for students and a trading post for English papers.

For at least four years, Palo Alto High School students have been submitting papers to their teachers through the website Turnitin.com, which allows them to generate an "originality report" on the document before handing it over.

"If there's any sentence that appears to have been copied, cut and pasted, they have the opportunity to change it before the paper is submitted," said teacher Shirley Tokheim, who is instructional supervisor for Paly's English Department.

"It's a way to set them up to succeed rather than to catch them."

Paly Principal Phil Winston said the school pays a licensing fee to Turnitin, which allows use across the school, with the English Department leading the way.

"We've had it for at least the three years I've been here. It really picked up a few years ago, and this year we're educating students what it means to turn it in and what to look for on the color-coded analytics," Winston said.

A paper turned in through the website is time-stamped and gives the student the option of running an originality check ahead of time, Tokheim said.

Mistakes can occur when students are up against a deadline, she said.

"It can be a problem if students don't have time to run it through Turnitin and have inadvertently cut and pasted without citing it in their paper."

Tokheim demonstrated Turnitin's "originality check" feature with a student paper about "Thank You for the Light," an F. Scott Fitzgerald essay that the New Yorker published last summer after having originally rejected it in 1936.

Turnitin generated a "Match Overview" for the Paly student's paper, showing that identical quotes had been submitted at Princeton University and the Elk Grove Unified School District, among other places.

But the matching quotes turned out to be legitimate — and properly cited — pieces from the original text.

Tokheim said the English Department is working on standardized training for students on the proper use of Turnitin, including an instructional video being created by students.

"There have been some misunderstandings that caused some students either not to check or to make some assumptions that got them into trouble, so we're trying to clarify and educate them. The video should help a lot," she said.

Tokheim said she gets about five cases a year of serious plagiarism, and "they're all hard.

"It can be a phrase, a sentence or multiple sentences that have been cut and pasted and not attributed. By the time they get to me it usually involves parents, and everybody's upset."

Besides changing things for students, widespread use of Turnitin has transformed the grading experience for teachers.

"It's kind of a shift when you go from reading papers at your kitchen table to reading online," Tokheim said.

"It frees up this feeling that you have hundreds of papers to go through — you still do, but it's just different.

"It's a lot neater, and it forces you to make more global comments, which I think are better for students."

At the start of a semester Tokheim still asks students to turn in their first few papers in hard copy so she can read them the old-fashioned way.

Because of her duties as instructional supervisor Tokheim teaches just two English classes of 35 students each, plus a smaller "restart" class for students needing to make up credit.

Other teachers, though, can have as many as five classes with 30 students apiece.

"Each paper can take at least 10 minutes, so it's like a part-time job outside of teaching and planning."

With English class sizes creeping up in recent years, "We're always trying to find different ways to have students continue to write and find ways to give them feedback," Tokheim said.

Staff Writer Chris Kenrick can be emailed at ckenrick@paweekly.com.

Comments

Posted by PNFW, a resident of Crescent Park
on Feb 22, 2013 at 7:56 pm

That PAUSD teachers are viewing turn-it-in.com as a tool to help students is commendable. So often teachers in venues other than the PAUSD have viewed on-line tools as a means to 'catch' and 'punish' students rather than as tools to educate students about the seriousness of doing their own critical thinking in their writing. Also, as a person with great empathy for the paper load that teachers must bear, I trust that PAUSD teachers will continue to grade papers with an eye on the objective -- to honor students' efforts and to help students to order their thoughts in a clear manner. In the interview, Ms. Tokheim gives strong evidence that PAUSD English teachers care about their students' thinking processes above all other considerations. Aren't we lucky to have such teachers!


Posted by Ridiculoso, a resident of College Terrace
on Feb 25, 2013 at 7:51 am

That is just ridiculous that a deadline is at midnight! What moron does such a thing? Why can't kids turn in the papers at school, on or before their realistic due date?


Don't miss out on the discussion!
Sign up to be notified of new comments on this topic.

Email:


Post a comment

Posting an item on Town Square is simple and requires no registration. Just complete this form and hit "submit" and your topic will appear online. Please be respectful and truthful in your postings so Town Square will continue to be a thoughtful gathering place for sharing community information and opinion. All postings are subject to our TERMS OF USE, and may be deleted if deemed inappropriate by our staff.

We prefer that you use your real name, but you may use any "member" name you wish.

Name: *

Select your neighborhood or school community: * Not sure?

Comment: *

Verification code: *
Enter the verification code exactly as shown, using capital and lowercase letters, in the multi-colored box.

*Required Fields